Muth II, Thomas M

Judge overview and comparisons

Thomas M Muth II serves at the Mobile Hearing Office in Alabama. In FY 2025 (most recent available), Thomas M Muth II decided 325 cases, including 226 favorable decisions, 57 unfavorable decisions, and 42 dismissals (cases closed without a decision on the merits — typically withdrawals, untimely filings, or abandonment). Their favorable rate was 69.5% and their unfavorable rate was 17.5%.

At Mobile Hearing Office, the pooled favorable rate is 59.9%. Their favorable rate of 69.5% is 9.7 percentage points above the office average. Their unfavorable rate is 4.4 percentage points lower than the office rate of 22.0%.

Compared with the national pooled favorable rate of 48.7%, their favorable rate is substantially higher than the national average by 20.8 percentage points. The national unfavorable rate is 34.9%.

Their dismissal rate of 12.9% was 5.2 percentage points below the office rate of 18.2%.