Administrative Law Judge

Judge John Costello

Listed by SSA as: Costello, John P

Rochester, NY · New York

Had a hearing with this judge? Rate your experience

Judge overview and comparisons

John P Costello serves at the Rochester, NY in New York. In FY 2025 (most recent available), John P Costello decided 83 cases, including 59 favorable decisions, 22 unfavorable decisions, and 2 dismissals (cases closed without a decision on the merits — typically withdrawals, untimely filings, or abandonment).

Allowance (approval) rate: 71.1%. The unfavorable rate was 26.5%.

At Rochester, NY, the pooled favorable rate is 66.0%. Their favorable rate of 71.1% is 5.1 percentage points above the office average.

Compared with the national pooled favorable rate of 48.7%, their favorable rate is substantially higher than the national average by 22.4 percentage points. The national unfavorable rate is 34.9%.

Their dismissal rate of 2.4% was 7.9 percentage points below the office rate of 10.3%.

Community ratings

Anonymous category ratings for Costello, John P. Individual ratings are not shown.

Overall average: No ratings yet · 0 reviews

Professional demeanor
No ratings yet
Timeliness (hearing started on time; decision issued promptly)
No ratings yet
Listened to testimony
No ratings yet
Clarity of questions
No ratings yet

See community ratings for Rochester, NY

FY 2025 Disposition Statistics

Total cases83
Favorable rate71.1%
Unfavorable rate26.5%
Favorable decisions59

Outcome breakdown

Hearing and case resources

View the Rochester, NY office page and the New York state overview. To understand what happens after a denial, read the ALJ hearing guide and the five-step disability evaluation; the hearing FAQ explains what to expect on hearing day.

MyHearingJudge provides public Social Security hearing judge disposition statistics for research purposes.

Other judges with published dispositions at this hearing office.

See how this rate compares nationally

Cite this page

Embed this

The badge uses the latest complete fiscal year. It may differ from a period you selected on this page.