Administrative Law Judge
Gaffney, John
Phoenix Downtown Hearing Office · Arizona
Judge overview and comparisons
John Gaffney serves at the Phoenix Downtown Hearing Office in Arizona. Through July 31, 2026 in FY 2026, John Gaffney decided 451 cases, including 287 favorable decisions, 94 unfavorable decisions, and 70 dismissals (cases closed without a decision on the merits — typically withdrawals, untimely filings, or abandonment). Their favorable rate was 63.6% and their unfavorable rate was 20.8%.
Year-to-date data: This fiscal year is still in progress, so totals will grow and should not be compared with completed fiscal years.
At Phoenix Downtown Hearing Office, the pooled favorable rate is 45.4%. Their favorable rate of 63.6% is substantially higher than the office average by 18.2 percentage points. Their unfavorable rate is 12.8 percentage points lower than the office rate of 33.6%.
Compared with the national pooled favorable rate of 48.1%, their favorable rate is substantially higher than the national average by 15.6 percentage points. The national unfavorable rate is 35.3%.
Their dismissal rate of 15.5% was 5.4 percentage points below the office rate of 21.0%.
FY 2026 Disposition Statistics
Outcome breakdown
- Fully favorable: 273
- Partially favorable: 14
- Unfavorable: 94
- Dismissals: 70
- Other dispositions: 0
MyHearingJudge provides public Social Security hearing judge disposition statistics for research purposes.